• The thing I miss most from reddit is the ability to find decently sized communities for extremely niche topics. Lemmy just isn’t big enough to support that. However, I certainly don’t miss it enough to actually go back to using Reddit. There’s other places to go for that (like Discord servers / Matrix spaces).

    • My new thing is im trying to gradually reduce my topic specific questions in catchall Ask comms like this and instead submitting to the actual community that concerns it

      Itll be slow but hopefully that can meaningfully shift my own stuff to help beef up the existing topical comms, if everyone does something similar we may actually get somewhere.

      Sometimes im just gonna post here cuz its easier and people sort of know my deal already but i do intend to try to put things where they belong in hopes of making Lemmy more like that in terms of stronger non-centralized topical comms that are more likely to have domain-experts or at least more knowledgeable than is likely to be found in general purpose Asks

      • ASK, is almost all filled Propaganda bots posting, or AI posted. it always involves some kind of ragebaiting.

    • Exactly. I haven’t seen either a woodworking or sewing project over here since I joined, as one example.

      No terrible first attempt at dovetails, no probable not first attempt at macarons, no woman wearing the sweater she just knit from alpaca wool.

      And books. If I wanted a new scifi book here, I’d likely get 0-1 responses. There’s no book community here.

        • You’re kidding. How is that even possible? Conservative AI bots pushing for those uneducated masses? Probably, with 51% bot/AI post populations on social media.

          In real life, I see the younger generation carrying physical, paper books around at work. We have them in my house, and the people in my house keep one in their cars for wait times.

        • I stay on the main feed (app) and just block stuff I’m not interested. I haven’t seen that one break through yet. Thanks!

    • Exactly. You can find an active subreddit for fucking anything. Find a new anime and want to discuss it? There’s an active sub for that. Find a cool bug and want to identify it? There’s an active sub for that. Want to ask a doctor for casual (off-the-record) medical advice? There’s an active sub for that.

      But with Lemmy, the first would probably land in a more generic c/Anime, while the latter ones might struggle to find an appropriate community at all. Because even if the specific communities exist, the chances of them being active enough to get a response are low.

  • r/asksciencefiction brought up a lot of great ideas and interesting arguments.

    One of my favorites was ‘what if the Addams Family had discovered baby Kal-El?’

    • There was a whole constellation of fiction-related communities that flew below the largest ones (r/books, television, etc). Those large “front-pagers” often ended up acting as a filter, so places like r/asksciencefiction and r/characterrant could have decent discussion.

      You can’t find any of that here, let alone communities dedicated to specific fictional series or settings.

  • Yes and no. I miss some of the more niche communities and some subreddits that had great sources of information.

    But I don’t miss the other 90%.

  • I love that you can binge a TV show from 5-10 years ago and then go to Reddit and see all of the post episode discussions. The next time I watch a trashy reality TV show, I will miss not having Reddit post episode analysis. When I’ve looked in the past, the best I could find on Lemmy was someone posting nudes of contestants from past seasons. The makeup and skincare subreddits were super informative. IDK if they’re still good since I’ve been mostly Reddit free lately.

    • 9 days

      this! we need a trash tv community that’s going strong so I can discuss my love-hate for Love Is Blind

  • Smaller, niche subs. The state/city subs. The specific career subs. The hobby subs.

  • 9 days

    A lot of the communities I frequent simply never made it. They were too niche, or it simply didn’t fit Lemmy.

    Though I’d argue that what I miss more is the usability. Old Reddit and RES is a wonderful experience. Lemmy and Alexandrite are closer to new Reddit than old, including the poorer performance.

    I know there are some interfaces that emulate the old Reddit experience, but they lack the RES integration that makes old Reddit particularly nice to use.

    • Amateur porn is how every site gets big. Tumblr was able to get as big as Reddit by allowing amateur porn and Reddit only managed to keep up by doing the same. The only reason you don’t hear about Tumblr now is because they stepped allowing it and scrubbed all their content. By the time they reversed their decision only two weeks later, everyone had moved over to Reddit, their momentum was lost, and the damage was terminal.

  • Some sizeable language learning communities. Unless I’ve been living under a rock and some c/LearnJapanese or c/tokipona on some Lemmy instance absolutely took off

    I also miss some gaming communities, but those being connected to some commercial product I can get they don’t do well on Lemmy 😅

  • I miss ShittyMorph. Randomly coming across one of those Hell in a Cell comments randomly always made me day.

  • The content, engagement, and quality of conversations are much better here on Lemmy, and the platform feels considerably less saturated.

    Unfortunately, what Reddit used to be, and what made it great, is long gone. That being said, the API changes were the nail in the coffin, not the sole reason for its decline. Reddit had already been on a downward trajectory for years before that.

    The one thing I still appreciate about Reddit is that content gets refreshed much more frequently than it does on Lemmy. However, even that isn’t enough to keep me there for more than a few visits a week, usually out of sheer boredom.

  • 9 days

    I miss the ol’ reddit switcheroo and also I miss the “you’re thinking of Y. X is when (something X is definitely not)”

  • 9 days

    /r/ModernMoo , which (IIRC) is just some guy from Ireland who likes posting pictures of his cows. I unsubscribed from virtually every sub before I left, but I am pretty sure I am still technically subbed to that one.