• 11 days

    If a delivery robot can’t reliably distinguish traffic lights from advertising, it’s clearly not ready for public roads. Urban environments are unpredictable by nature, not exceptional circumstances. And a software failure could affect an entire fleet, not just one robot. Autonomous delivery may have real benefits, but public safety cannot become collateral damage in the race to automate everything.

    • 11 days

      Unfortunately we may be forced to remove all advertising from public spaces to make them safer to robots.

      • Fuck the robots. Remove advertising because it’s a cancer on society, by all means, but any robot that can’t deal with this kind of thing shouldn’t be allowed on the streets.

        • Advertisement is just misappropriated space that could have been used for art.

    • Wheres the proof its not reliable? I think there’s about a hundred of them operating in the city since at least 2022 based on what I can see. So just based on the information here I’d have to assume each one causes an accident once every (100*365*(2026-2022)) = 146000 days which seems pretty okay to me, even if its a tenth of that.

      • There’s a substantial difference between mitigating for errors by human drivers and accepting a percentage of undesirable behaviour as part of a system run by logic.

      • “Don’t worry about those other 99 time bombs! Only one has gone off so far. So if we multiply the number of days they’ve been ticking by the total number of bombs, it is clear that their explosions only happen once every four centuries!”

        Idiot. [admittedly uncalled for]

        • 11 days

          Well, you do need to consider things in context, right?

          Captain_solanum is right about how math works. The thing to consider is the safety of these delivery bots relative to the alternatives. How often do delivery drivers get into/cause accidents? It’s not never, but without the actual numbers we can’t really say if these bots are more problematic.

          It’s difficult to compare these two delivery methods because they’re inherently quite different, but ultimately that is what we have to do if we want to figure out which is actually more of a danger.

          But accountability is really important here. If companies want to keep using tech this way, they need to be accountable for the actions of their technology. Because these devices exist in a physical world with real consequences. You cannot be allowed to get off the hook by saying “oops, just a glitch, it won’t happen again”.

          Also, you called him an idiot, but you may have also missed his point. We could just not outright insult each other.

          • Yeah, accountability is the entire point. Are the corporations, executives, and shareholders going to be held responsible for this?

            Also, every human driver is different. So it’s up to each driver as an individual to ensure they’re following traffic rules and driving safely. Human minds are also complex and capable of adapting to evolving circumstances, even at a moment’s notice, to deal with unexpected situations when they arise, such as near-miss emergencies.

            Machines don’t have that; they’re algorithmic and deterministic, which means there will always be some possibility of events outside the scope of their programming.

            Also, comparing the robots to human drivers isn’t a good comparison, because as far as we’re concerned the hardware and software are nearly identical between each robot. So if one of them was capable of causing a multi-vehicle accident, that means they all are.

            So calculating probability using something similar to the manhours of each robot on the road is foolish. What they did was (incidents) ÷ (robots × time), to make it look like a comically small chance of having an accident.

            A more accurate formula would be (1 – (incidents ÷ time))^(number of robots)^

            And that gives you the probability of (time) elapsing without incident. The more robots there are, the smaller that number gets, meaning the likelihood of an accident increases with each additional robot. Not decreases.

            So for example (1 – (1 accident ÷ 4 years))^(100 robots)^ = 0.75100

            In other words, without a software update requiring significant technological improvements, with 100 of these robots on the road, the chances of going another 4 years without an accident is on the magnitude of 3.207 × 10^(-13)

            I’ll leave you to determine what that makes the likelihood of x number of incidents per year.

            You’re right that I didn’t have to call them an idiot though, I apologize for that. My temper was a bit spun up from arguing with trolls in a different thread, but I shouldn’t have let that seep out here.

  • 11 days

    Don’t shift the blame to bright ad boards or similar external factors. If the device can’t deal with it, it does not belong in that environment.

    • 11 days

      No no, let’s put the blame on bright ad boards, and require cities to remove that form of advertisement. You know, for safety.

  • 11 days

    I hope they told their bus drivers to not brake for those robots next time. If stopping in time means putting the passengers at risk of injury, run the damn clanker over.

    • What ass backwards timeline we’re living in that we got Asimov’s three laws on backwards? That a human being cannot harm a robot? 🤬

      • If you’ve ever actually read any of the books you’d know that using these laws as actual laws is a dumb move. The paradoxes caused by them are a pretty central theme.

        • Yeah like one of the stories in i Robot, the people were going die because the robot couldn’t break one of the three rules and went haywire. Think that was the issue in most of the stories.

        • Yeah, the actual purpose of the laws was to produce interesting (when involving Susan Calvin) or amusing (when involving Powell and Donovan) stories.

          Still some form of protection for humans is needed.

          If a robot (or any other corporate product or activity) causes injury everyone in the corporate chain of responsibility (especially board members and stockholders) should be criminally liable.

      • also robots are pratically blameless, thats why they are made, so it obfuscates the true owners.

      • The entire damn point of the three laws is that they don’t work and cause more harm then good… The paradox of the laws is the whole point!

        • What paradox? I thought the rules were considered a good idea in the stories.

          • They are considered a good idea yes. But the entire point is that the notion that they are a good idea IS the flaw. Its literally a case of “just because a smart person thinks its a good idea, doesn’t make it one”.

            The story and stories based on it that properly understand it. All look into how 3 simple well meaning laws which on paper sound and look good. Cause horrific unintended side effects, and harm humanity frequently to comical extremes.

            As the saying goes, “The best laid plans of mice and men can still go wrong.”.

    • 11 days

      It’s not that easy. Running the thing over is also dangerous for the people in the bus. The driver must decide.

    • In split second decisions, you don’t want to run the risk that the driver thought for a moment it’s a robot and not a small kid. Safety first. Let the robot go and sue the company.

    • 11 days

      Just asking for them to hit a runaway stroller they mistook for a delivery robot

  • 11 days

    Oh nooo the robot was blinded by traffic lights says the company.

    WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK.

    • 11 days

      It cannot be blinded. What an incredibly bold statement, unless they aim to go bankrupt soon anyway

    • I’m not saying the robot is “right”, but the number of people crusing around with their high beams on as a matter of corse, is as they saying goes, too damn high. So I can absolutely believe that a vehicle’s high beams limited its “vision” because that regularly happens to me driving and as a pedestrian.

      Now if the robot fled the scene that’s a completely different issue for which it’s operators are responsible.

      • I’m not saying that you’re “wrong”, but the idea of giving the benefit of the doubt to a piece of technology in service of a corporation is, as the saying goes, bonkers.

      • If those high beams are legal, then all that means is the robot can’t safely operate under normal/legal conditions. If it can’t operate safely, why is it allowed in public?

        • 11 days

          High beams are NOT legal in the city. And they were in all likelyhood not being used in this scenario.

  • Whomever allowed that robot outside is to blame. If they have grievances, they can sue whomever wrote the software or built the device. Keep sending the buck up until it reaches the top.

    • 11 days

      The responsibility should lie with the company that decided the robot was safe enough to deploy. How it distributes liability among its developers, manufacturers and suppliers is its problem, not the public’s.

      • 11 days

        When it’s a criminal matter, the assigment of blame is absolutely a public matter. If you or I caused a car accident with irresponsible use of an RC car or a consumer drone, we would be facing criminal prosecution. The fact that no one is likely to face charges in this case is a huge failure of public policy.

        • 11 days

          💯 That’s an important distinction: Civil liability determines who pays for the damage, while criminal responsibility addresses whether someone’s negligence was serious enough to constitute a crime. And that question absolutely deserves public scrutiny. Automation must not become a shield against criminal accountability.

          • Who pays for the damage is also a civil matter. Fine everyone in the chain of responsibility, up to and including board members and stockholders, scaling the fines in proportion to their wealth.

            Need to fine the parasites on top billions so that they’ll feel it as much as the engineer who is fined hundreds? So be it, fuck them, they’re just as responsible if not more, and should have been taxed to the point of not being able to accumulate those billions anyway.

      • No, fuck the company, assessing responsibility should be a public matter.

        The law should be designed to make sure that no worker is more afraid of their boss than of breaking it, and to ensure that the executives, board members, and stackholders making the company’s decisions (or implicitly endorsing them) are held responsible for their consequences.

  • 11 days

    The robot was heard yelling “Bite my shiny metal ass!” as it ran away.

  • The robot tried to cross the street against a Don’t Walk signal it should have obeyed. That behavior is a defect, which the manufacturer should be responsible for. Whether the robot “fled the scene” is only an issue if the robot is smart enough to recognize that it caused a problem, and left to avoid the consequences - which I srsly doubt. I mean if the robot were a live dog we wouldn’t expect it to understand the situation enough to flee, we would assume it just ran off because it’s a dog.

    • Is it run remotely ny a human?

      Edit: the ‘ny’ said ‘by’ for 2 days before some mod or software agent decided to modify my post and change the spelling. WTF ?

    • These techs are seemingly developed with minimal coordination between companies let alone governments. With serious effort and planning, this could’ve been avoided with software providing both real time info or direct link with the city traffic system.

  • As the spokesperson put it, the robot’s actions may legally constitute fleeing the scene of a traffic incident, meaning Starship Technologies could very well be on the hook for the incident.

    I don’t understand. It darted into a moving bus regardless, even if it hadn’t fled. The bus sure as hell isn’t responsible…

    • Yes, the real issue is that it disobeyed a Don’t Walk signal, which is clearly a defect for a robot allowed on public streets. People saying it “fled the scene” are just making noise.

    • 11 days

      “The fault lies with one of our subcontractors, one of the janitors is to blame, send him to prison. Anyway, we will keep doing business as we are a corporation and therefore a person and therefore none of us who own the company are at fault whatsoever.”

    • 11 days

      There was no actual collision

      The injuries were from hitting the brakes. I’ve certainly has to brake for people and animals in the roadway before, never considered it an incident. Guess it’s different because there were injuries in the bus, which I wouldn’t have expected from just braking

      • Ok, but that’s still the robot’s fault. I’m sure the driver thought it was an animal or child at first. People don’t get to just wander into the road against a light.

  • It’s not “the robot fled”, it’s “a company put a unsafe robot onto a public street and should not be allowed to operate them at least until they’ve proven that their robots are really safe and will not flee from further accidents”

    • This is one of those times that government oversight should’ve been overbearing since it involves street use.

    • 11 days

      We need to hold CEOs and board members criminally liable for the shit their corporations do. Watch all sorts of bullshit just clear off the map.

    • 10 days

      Whether the robot left the scene after the fact is basically irrelevant. What were the police going to do if the robot was still there when they turned up, question it?

      • Yes, of course. Take the serial number. Check, if the vehicle had any problems. Like you would do with a normal car after an accident. Request the data from the company. That doesn’t really work if the robot flees

  • So, a hit-and-run.

    I think the legal principle of liability is that a company is fully liable for the damage that their products cause. “It was an automation” or “it was a robot” is not an excuse.

    So, maybe the consequence should be the permanent cancellation of the driving license of the responsible persons? If nobody else, the CEO of that company?

    • They caused an accident and then fled the scene, jail time seems most appropriate for the CEO and everyone underneath him who agreed this robot was fit to be out and crossing roads.

    • 11 days

      We absolutely have to implement to hold CEOs and upper management and stakeholders accountable for what their corporations do. They always blame some subcontractor that takes the hit, pay a trivial fine that doesn’t really affect their bottom line, and keep on doing business.

      Capitalism HAS to be reigned in, and personal responsibility is the way to do that in this case.

    • There actually was no hit. The bus slammed on the breaks. The injuries are most likely minor bumps and bruises. This article is sensationalist as fuck. This was essentially someone cutting the bus off in traffic. If it wasn’t a robot, it wouldn’t have been newsworthy.

      • 11 days

        …The fact that it WAS a fucking robot literally IS what makes it newsworthy, bro.