• 12 days

    The UK has been saturated with CCTV cameras of all sorts for decades so the frog has been thoroughly boiled on public opinion on them.

    • 11 days

      Even as an American, I’m well aware of the history around surveillance in Britain. V for Vendetta was largely a commentary on it, Radiohead has made some references to government/corporate oversight in their albums, etc.

  • 11 days

    The difference is ANPR is that Flock is a private business, collecting data and stalking people across the US for commercial purposes, which sold this data to law enforcement - meanwhile law enforcement were using the private sector to bypass the checks and balances of court warrants.

    In the UK, ANPR is an official tool, not private. Police need to get authorisation to use it, and it is not used for commercial purposes.

    It’s still wank, but it’s not quite as wank.

    • It’s not used for commercial purposes

      Maybe not in that way, but private car parks use ANPR all the time to fine you £70 for staying 1 minute over your allotted time

      • 11 days

        It’s the same technology, but it’s not the same network of cameras, is it? I’d assumed ParkingEye and the like would only have access to their own cameras that they had been contracted to set up by private land owners of car parks.

      • 11 days

        I was thinking on this when I wrote my comment above, and I’m not quite sure.

        Either there’s a muddying of terms, where you have ANPR as a technology (which anyone could implement), and the police have their own, separate network of ANPR cameras. Then the police can obtain footage from private cameras as needed through warrants.
        Or private entities submit their data to an ANPR database that the police maintain.

        Regardless, there’s not one big private network of ANPR cameras that the government have permitted to be installed on public land, and the police still have checks and balances in place to prevent abuse.

        • ANPR is just any camera with OCR targeted at reg plates.

          Police ANPR queries the Law Enforcement Data System, which contains data such as the car history, owner details, stolen cars, and persons of interest.

          Commercial ANPR queries the organisation’s proprietary database and also the publicly available DVLA data to gather the name and address of the owner.

          • 10 days

            Awesome, that’s pretty much what I thought.

            Just for clarity though, does the commercial ANPR automatically provide data to police, or is that data only available upon a lawful request with a court order?

            Also, the article mentions data being kept for a year. Is this a requirement for commercial ANPR?

            I’ll also add that requests to the public DVLA database are only lawful if they have actual need to request that information, eg to send a ticket for a breach in parking terms. They can’t access the name and address linked to every plate that drives by the camera.

  • The US is mad about them because its police force is uneducated, untrained and murderous. Whatever flaws the UK’s police have, it’s not nearly as bad, and having surveillance (in public) is not likely to result in you or your dog getting shot for no reason.

    • 11 days

      The US is (also) mad about them because it’s a violation of the 4th amendment of our constitution against unreasonable search.

      • 11 days

        And because US law enforcement have been using the private sector to bypass the need for a warrant.

      • I don’t really know the legal arguments that make surveillance of public places into searches, but let’s assume they exist and are valid… I still don’t think people would be that mad about it if you thought you could trust your police to use the information half-way responsibly.

        • 11 days

          police are untrustworthy in any country on earth.

    • 11 days

      Whatever flaws the UK’s police have, it’s not nearly as bad

      The only major difference between the US and UK police is the numbers that are armed.

      UK police are still full of the corrupt, racists, misogynists, rapists, child abusers and wife beaters.

      • The entire basis of policing in the two countries is different. This is reflected in their attitude and use of force, which is relevant when evaluating any new police power or tool.

      • Apart from the PSNI, CNC, large swathes of the BTP and specialist officers in every other force.

  • 11 days

    We don’t have “Flock-style” cameras at all. We have a statutory system with a strictly defined remit that was subject to years of argument, scrutiny and rewrites before it was turned on, not an invasive profit factory run by ruthless, messianic psychopaths. Secondly, our cops are all educated to degree level, they’re not just a bunch of otherwise futureless thugs who sit a three-week impossible-to-fail class and are given a gun. Neither the UK ANPR system nor police are perfect, far from it, but both are orders of magnitude better than what you have the Land Of The Free™.

    I know enough about the ANPR systems on public roads that the UK police have access to. Firstly, it’s centrally managed through the PNC and every single query is logged: each query has to me made by an authorised officer who signs in with a federated identity and has to make the query in the context of an investigation - any query made without that immediately launches to an internal investigation and instant no-questions-asked dismissal is on the cards for anyone who makes a query without official justification. You know how American cops can shoot a protester and go back to full work after a two-week fully-paid break? Last month a cop in the UK was fired and blocked from ever working in the police, as a security guard or even as a doorman for the rest of his life without any possibility of appeal. He stole a reusable carrier bag from a supermarket.

    Also, different people in different organisations have different levels of access. The DVLA can see if a particular license plate has been logged anywhere in a given month to see if an untaxed car is in use, for example, but they can’t see anything else. A traffic cop can see if a car has insurance, tax and an MOT certificate, but not the owner’s name or address. The biggest loophole at the moment is private car park owners who can ask the DVLA for the details of the owner of a car to issue parking fines, but that’s being clamped down on and, regardless, is nothing to do with public cameras.

    Also, also: as a public, statutory systen the UK system is subject to FOI and GDPR: anyone can demand a copy of all of their own records from it. Highly recommended.

  • 11 days

    It’s not like big brother was invisible, but it’s much more different in a hypercapitalist state where a private corporation tracks and sells and launder data for a shell government. I’d prefer uk to that any day, and that’s saying a lot

  • 12 days

    Policing by consent is what is different, in America police are often a private force for those in power

    • 11 days

      More specifically, Flock is a private company. Because it’s private and commercial, police can just purchase access and don’t need a warrant.

      ANPR in the UK is run by police. Using it falls under the same rules as any other police investigation.

  • 12 days

    The UK has surrendered their rights to a nanny state. They can’t even own pointy knives.

    • 11 days

      Oh no I’m not allowed a murderous weapon, what a restrictive country I live in I don’t know how I cope. The day I wasn’t able to randomly kill someone who cut me off in traffic. What an utterly appalling infringement on my freedoms.

      • That person is wrong anyway. We can carry a knife but there are restrictions. Some knifes are completely banned though, zombies, etc.

        I carry a 3" non-locking knife with me often. Totally legal.