It’s been showing up in eerie conversations I can’t legally share
- 23 days
It’s just rich people lying to themselves to justify doing whatever they wanted to do anyway and pretend it’s somehow in humanity’s long term interests. It’s not, and nothing the rich do ever is.
CombatWombat@feddit.onlineEnglish
23 daysEffective Altruism is a plausible-sounding framework, but the practitioners are literal insane people. Should you donate a fixed part of your earnings every pay period to the most effective charities? Yes! But after that, it basically all falls apart and suddenly you’re in Yudowsky’s weird sex cult donating money to some weird crypto scheme.
- 23 days
It’s a shallow, pointless ideology for super-rich motherfuckers who need a way to morally justify their tax evasion and the effects of the poverty that their lifestyles and business practices create.
- 23 days
It’s just capitalism and econ101 duct-taped and stapled to utilitarianism. Jeremy Bentham is crying.
It’s for psychopath tech bros who’ve got spiders in their brainz.
For example, imagine a myopic billionaire who imagines himself “saving” humanity. If his contributions happen to cause suffering to people alive today, so what? He’s saving “trillions” of people, just in the future. Obviously this means that of all people alive, this billionaire is the only one who really matters. Certainly not Ukrainians who die because he turned off their battlefield communication… hypothetically.
- 23 days
We should have required some basic social science or political science courses in comp sci from the start
- 23 days
This is worth a listen for some background on how EA thinking has been influencing the AI world:
https://podcastaddict.com/better-offline/episode/235206311
Short version is that it’s a cult that believes that they are about to bring about a god, and need to ensure they are the ones in control.
- 23 days
To me it just means donating money for mosquito nets, vitamin a supplements, and other “boring” ideas that have a high impact without costing a lot, and doing it through companies that have low overhead costs, so as large a fraction of my donations go to the ones who need it.
But I reckon from the replies to this post that people feel it’s been hijacked by the super rich to feel better about themselves?
- 23 days
Tangent: I went to a Rotary Club meeting once, and it was just a bunch of rich people patting each other on the back for being nice to the poors.
- stoy@lemmy.zipEnglish23 days
Oh yeah, isn’t that the point of rotary, to be a club for internal admiration?
they are enormously genorous for not just ending the homeless problem with mass execution
- 23 days
I like the all-lowercase concept of effective altruism (making the most out of limited resources) but the organizations claiming that name are shady af
- 23 days
This is the funniest thing I’ve read in a while I was just telling a friend about the trolley problem this morning thank you
- 23 days
Sounds like post-modern Western BS. Altruism/prosociality/solidarity are already words, the “effective” just makes it sound like something a scammer would say.
- 22 days
To me it always sounded like victim blaming TBH. Some poor people don’t deserve to be helped, so us effective altruists (who do things to make people poorer) will weigh their souls and help those who want to be helped.
- HelloThere@sh.itjust.worksEnglish23 days
It’s complicated, but first things first you need to differentiate between the philosophy and the EA “movement”, led by Giving What We Can and others. The latter is shill bullshit and rich people power plays.
The former, set out mostly by Will MacAskill, is an application of future conscious utilitarianism within a capitalist system.
Or in a less wanky way, given you as a poor schmuck can only afford to give a few quid to charities each month, how can you “help the most”.
At the simplest level, giving £5/m to a local soup kitchen ran by volunteers who spend all of that money on food is probably more effective than giving the same amount to a major charity with hundreds of employees.
I hope that example also suggests how it itself is not actually straight forward. The local charity with volunteers may just objectively be shit at what they are trying to do, and all the money is wasted.
Point being, you, nor EA, know that unless you do the work to find out. While the principal of harm reduction is absolutely valid, it does not replace advocating for changes to the underlying system.
- 23 days
No opinion, but the only guy I personally, know who is into it, is a poly-sex-fiend-genocide-denier.
So it kind of tracks with recent posts about EA.
- 22 days
I think that they face a fundamental problem in Hume’s guillotine, where trying to rigorously define “the best” outcomes can lead to strange results when done in an echo chamber. This is best exemplified when taken to the extremes, e.g. the Zizians, an offshoot group of EA who have been rightly disavowed.





